On
Sunday's episode of "60 Minutes" (11/30/08),
Lara Logan
profiled Army hero Private Monica Brown, an 18-year-old medic who was
awarded the Silver Star. Yet as wonderful as Brown's heroics were,
Logan's profile could not shake the impression that it really wanted to
get in some cheap shots at the United States military. Here's how Logan
opened her piece:
Private Monica Brown is only the second woman to be awarded the
Silver Star since the Second World War. She’s an Army medic who
risked her own life to save two critically wounded paratroopers of
the 82nd airborne division in Afghanistan.
O.K. so far. But then Logan abruptly switched gears:
Under Army regulations, women cannot be assigned to front-line
combat units, but in the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq today,
that’s exactly where they often end up. Some male soldiers aren’t
so happy about that, including members of Private Brown’s own unit.
But her superior officers say she’s a hero, a hero who earned one of
the military’s highest awards for exceptional valor when she was
only 18 years old.
First ... That women "cannot be assigned to front-line combat units"
is a theme that Logan hammered throughout her piece. The problem?
Private Brown was not on a front-line combat mission. As Logan's own
story indicated, Brown was a medic in a unit that had been "searching
for weapons in a village" when it was ambushed while returning to
base. (By the way, Logan identifies those who ambushed our men and woman
simply as "hidden enemy fighters.")
Logan pressed a pair of Army commanders on this point.
LOGAN: Women are not supposed to be, according to the strict
guidelines, are not supposed to be on [the] front line of combat.
COLONEL MARTIN SCHWEITZER: We do not assign our female
soldiers to the infantry and the armor. We do attach female
soldiers to units for a specific mission for a specific period of
time, absolutely in accordance with Army policy ... Anywhere you
go outside of the forward operating base you can, you know, run into
the threat, or a threat.
Yet even after being debunked by Col. Schweitzer, Logan tried to
press the issue with Brown herself.
LOGAN: The Army has very strict rules about women not being on
the front line. And, I mean, there's no question that you were on
the front line.
PVT. BROWN: There is no front line in Afghanistan or Iraq.
You go out on missions. Whether it be humanitarian aid or, you
know, help building schools, or pulling support for another unit
while they're building roads, or searching for Taliban. You go out
there and you do your job. And you don't know what's gonna happen.
Anything could happen.
Oops. After being refuted twice, you'd think that Logan would have wanted to edit out the
"front-line" theme in her profile. But she didn't. Why let the facts get
in the way of a good swipe at the U.S. Military?
Another theme that Logan hammers is that "some male soldiers,"
"including members of Private Brown’s own unit," "aren’t so happy about"
serving with women.
Yet what did Logan present to back this up? Almost nothing!
Logan states Brown "never heard any complaints from the men in the
unit." Also:
PVT. BROWN: ... [T]hat's how I got treated, like one of the guys.
You are just like any of the other guys.
LOGAN: Some of the guys may not feel that way.
PVT. BROWN: I've never heard any difference.
COL. SCHWEITZER: Her performance and her actions that day were
phenomenal, they were heroic and they were properly acknowledged.
Those kids are alive today. I think that says it all.
It turns out the "some men," "some soldiers," and "members of her own
unit" who aren't happy are actually one guy, a critically wounded
soldier whom the show claims to have spoken with briefly on the phone.
LOGAN: [B]oth of those (critically wounded) men, [Specialist
Stanson] Smith and [Specialist Larry] Spray, declined to give "60
Minutes" an interview. When we asked why, Smith said flat out women
have no business being on the front line. The men who did talk to us
did not feel that way, and said Brown performed as well as any man
on the battlefield.
Call me a skeptic or a cynic, but Smith's answer doesn't pass the
smell test. The guy - critically wounded, by the way - declines an
interview, and when asked why, he says that "women have no business
being on the front line"? Sorry, but that simply sounds - well -
weird. And looking at
Logan's
awful record of shoddy journalism and bias, I have a tough time
trusting her. Of course, I could be very wrong, and it all really did
go down that way.
Thank you, Private Brown. You are a hero. And thank you to all our
men and women in uniform! It's just too bad that journalists like Logan
can't do a nice story without taking cheap, baseless swipes at you.